A Tale of Two Dahmers: A Review of Netflix's Dahmer-Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story" vs "My Friend Dahmer"

Two portrayals of one of history's most notorious serial killers have emerged from the shadows: Netflix’s “Dahmer – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story,” starring Evan Peters, and “My Friend Dahmer,” featuring Ross Lynch. As someone whose childhood was colored by the charming antics of Disney Channel heartthrob Ross Lynch, it feels almost surreal to compare him to Evan Peters’ chilling embodiment of the infamous murderer. Yet, as I dive into the depths of their respective performances, it becomes clear that Peters’ portrayal captivates a more profound exploration of the dark psyche behind Dahmer.

“My Friend Dahmer” is an intriguing take, focusing on the adolescent years of Jeffrey Dahmer, providing a lens through which we can understand the boy before the monster emerged. Ross Lynch, known for his sunshine and song, dives into the complexities of a troubled youth trying to fit in while battling his inner demons. While Lynch brings a sense of empathy and innocence to his role—highlighting Dahmer’s struggles with loneliness and rejection—his portrayal sometimes veers too close to a ‘sad boy’ archetype that leaves viewers yearning for a deeper connection to the horrors that would later unfold.

On the other hand, Evan Peters in “Dahmer – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story” delivers a performance that is as haunting as it is mesmerizing. Peters steps into the shoes of the infamous killer with an intensity that chills the marrow. He offers a multifaceted view of Dahmer, exploring not only his gruesome crimes but also the psychological scars that shaped him. From the moment Peters appears on screen, his nuanced portrayal pulls the audience into a dark abyss, forcing us to confront the uncomfortable truths about humanity. He embodies Dahmer not just as a monster but as a complex character trapped in a cycle of horror—his charisma making him all the more terrifying.

Visually, Netflix’s series presents a stark and gritty world that contrast

s sharply with the more subdued and almost nostalgic tone of “My Friend Dahmer.” The cinematography and direction in “Dahmer – Monster” heighten the viewer's anxiety, creating a palpable tension throughout the episodes, while the dramatic score resonates with the underlying theme of chaos lurking beneath the surface. Peters' performance is supported by a powerful narrative that sheds light on systemic failures and societal indifference, making it a rich tapestry for viewers to dissect.

While Lynch's portrayal has its merits—offering a glimpse into the early life of a killer—Peters elevates the story to a whole new level. His performance transcends mere imitation, delving into the depths of madness and despair. As someone who grew up enjoying the wholesome charm of Lynch's characters, watching Peters’ transformation into a figure of dread and complexity serves as a reminder that the path to evil is as convoluted as it is tragic.

While both films offer valuable explorations of Jeffrey Dahmer’s life, it is Evans Peters’ hauntingly vivid performance in “Dahmer – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story” that echoes long after the credits roll. In a world where the line between hero and villain blurs, Peters reminds us that even the darkest narratives merit examination beyond the surface. So, while Ross Lynch will always hold a special place in my childhood memories, it is Peters who has carved a lasting imprint in the realm of true crime storytelling.